Skip to main content

How to Improve Cold Email Conversion Rates?

4 mins read

06 May 2025

Here’s the truth - consumers are becoming more cynical when it comes to online marketing. Marketers who have overused the same old tactics have caused a spike in emails ending up in the spam folder. However, you can still turn your email marketing around with a solid strategy. Here’s a guide to help enhance your email prospecting and improve cold email response rates.

Make sure you are reaching out to the right person

Before you even write that email, you should have already done some research and determined the individuals whom you believe would benefit from the product you are offering. Do proper due diligence on their demographic and psychographic traits. A rule of thumb that you shouldn’t neglect is that you should always strive to target the person who has influence in the purchasing decision. If you have a product that is focused on B2B companies, LinkedIn is a great resource when researching for key decision makers within a company.

Skip the generic subject lines

This is a no-brainer and you would probably find this tip in similar articles on the web. But it is worth mentioning that the first thing your prospect will read can make or break your chances. Steer away from writing vague offers that would usually end up being marked as spam. Avoid words that trigger anti-spam systems that automatically block your messages. Instead, try to write well targeted subject lines, even better if they mention the customer's needs or pain points. It shows from the get-go that you understand your target audience and that your product is relevant to them.

Make sure your opening paragraph is worth reading

Don’t waste your perfectly crafted subject by following it up with a poorly written, boring opening paragraph. Aim to make it interesting while also keeping it short and straight to the point. Make sure you add value to your prospects’ lives, so do your research and tailor-fit your pitches in all communications.  Personalisation takes a whole lot of work, but it can be the key to your cold email campaign’s success.

Always include a call to action

Avoid confusing your readers that they end up wondering “so what?” or “what now?” after reading your message. State a clear call-to-action (CTA) at the end of your email. Do you want them to reply to your email, to sign up on your website, or to give you a call? Tell them clearly. But make sure to use the right nuanced words because you don’t want to sound like you are forcing them into a decision.

Don’t give up on the first attempt

People are busy, they might be interested but just forget to reply to you. Your email might also have gotten lost in the spam folder. Take initiative by following up a week or so after the initial contact. You’ll never know, you might be a gentle reminder away from making a sale. But don’t be a cyber nuisance by flooding their inbox, you wouldn’t want to be the guy they end up blocking.

Do you need help developing content? Contact us for a consultation – call 0418967352 or email [email protected]

Or drop us a line and we will contact you! 

 

Expect sharp insights on marketing, website design and development, data and AI solutions and more.

Related Posts

Categories

Tags

Subscribe to our newsletter

Grow your business with actionable digital marketing strategies. Subscribe now!

clients testimonials

See how we have made a difference

1

/

6

Peter Durning

Corp Centre

Candace is a pleasure to deal with! She understands how important the image of our business is and delivers results to ensure the said image is top notch!

Jose Alvarez

JYGA Group | Project Manager

We really liked the high standard of customer service we received from the moment we decided to get the project done. Great communication and the website looks like ten (not one) million dollars. We were really impressed with the attention to detail and can do attitude from the team at elephant in the boardroom. All the questions we asked were answered promptly and nothing was too difficult. The website looks fantastic and we will definitely recommend you to all our business partners.

Kiki Makrogiannis

CO-FOUNDER | TRADE MATCHER

Elephant didn't just build Trade Matcher a website, they built us a Directory that could facilitate us in achieving our business goal: "linking locals". The team are excellent! Knowledgable, creative, innovative, pro-active and sensative to urgency. Highly recommended.

Launce Kent

DIRECTOR | WEALTH EVOLUTION FINANCIAL PLANNING

We engaged Elephant in the Boardroom to design and develop a new landing page, then website for our company Wealth Evolution Financial Planning. The website was built quickly, to specifications and it exceeded our expectations. Elephant made themselves available throughout the build 24/7 and made the process simple. We are ecstatic with the results. We have recommended Elephant to many of our clients and will continue to do so.

MMSG

DIGITAL CHANNEL MANAGER

A truely professional company that will deliver as promised and beyond.

PETROTTERS

Founder

Elephant In The Boardroom has been nothing short of exceptional. Going above and beyond to ensure my business succeeds has really helped solidify the relationship between us. We will continue to work with them as our business grows. We would have no hesitation in recommending their work to our networks.

Jo Marcou

Next Millennium Group

Big thank you to Candace director of Elephant in the Boardroom for bringing our vision and branding to life! Your professionalism and attention to detail is second to none - you have truly exceeded our expectations. Above all you were an absolute pleasure to deal with no task being to big or small, regardless of time of day! I cannot recommend the fantastic team at Elephant In the Boardroom enough.

Dr Joe Donnoli

Inate Health

Elephant In The Boardroom have created for us a wonderful, interactive and easy to use website. They are an up and coming company that are keen to stamp their name in this very competitive market. I am certain that if my dealings with them are anything to go by they will certainly succeed. Thank you Adi and Candace and we all here at Mount Street Chiropractic Centre wish you all the success.

Nestor Sequera

SN Integrity | Technical Manager

Great work for the team at Elephant In The Boardroom. Great support and understanding customer needs. Well done.

let’s talk
let’s Connect

Got bold ideas?

Got a big vision? Let’s make it happen.

Your next chapter begins here. Let's connect and explore how we can design, build, and grow something extraordinary together. Book your free consultation.

You’ve made it this far and that’s no accident. If you’re looking to innovate, grow, or shift direction, everything starts with a simple conversation.